Friday, January 26, 2024

 Kickball!


 Everyone needs a paycheck! That includes children.  They need something to work toward which helps them to develop their self-control.  One of my answers to this question was kickball.  I lived to play kickball with my neighborhood friends on the dead end street where I grew up. Car!  Someone would yell if we were in the way but most of the time we owned the street.


When I taught second grade in Schenectady at the start of my career, I realized that my students never played outside and knew nothing about kickball.  So out we went! My second graders were hilarious to watch. They had no concept of zones even when I explained it to them.  If a ball went over toward third base, the entire outfield went after it. If a ball went out of bounds they would yell “vowel ball!”  So much fun!


I saw that kickball was a huge motivator for my students. I continued through the years with third, fourth and fifth grade classes in Massachusetts and Clifton Park. You could find me in the last half hour on Friday reffing a game. I had a few special roles that made it “Javarone” kickball. If a ball that was kicked hit me, it was an automatic out. One has to protect oneself!  No throwing the ball at a runner, they had to be tagged as in baseball. No stealing bases. No one except our class was allowed to play and everyone must play unless they had to “do some time.”


At the start of the year, there were always a few students who were insecure about playing. I'm sorry to say that they were almost always girls. However I would tell them the class story of Alicia. She was a big girl for 5th grade and kind of gangily. She did not want to play in September. As the year went on she became a tremendous kicker and everyone wanted her on their team. What if I had not given her the opportunity to discover something she did not know about herself?  Students with autism who came into our class every afternoon played as well.  Sometimes they had to run bases with their aid or one of their classmates,but it was part of understanding that we are a group. We are all together.  


An essential part of “Javarone” kickball was that it was only for our class. This bonded my students into teammates. That sense of “us” carried back to the classroom. We shared victories and defeats. Sometimes I'd forget what the score was. Next week all the teams would be different anyway. We laughed together.


A note about “doing some time.” If his student had done all their homework and class work for the week and if they had an unblemished record in whatever type of behavior plan the school was using, then they could line up when we pick teams. If they were lacking in work or behavior, they would have to sit out and watch the game begin. How long they had to sit depended on how their week had gone. Didn't get your parents signature on your agenda proving that you did your five and a half hours of reading at home?  That's going to cost you 10 minutes.  Maybe you just talked back to me once. That would mean you don't get to line up to make teams.  Whatever  the time, I always let students get back in the game at some point. If they felt like all hope was lost there would be no incentive to wait quietly outside the game. Once again, an opportunity to work on self-control.


Kickball may seem silly but I can tell you from my experience what a huge motivator it was and what a powerful tool it was in classroom management. Adults may need cash from their paycheck. My students had their paycheck in the form of kickball.  I am forever thankful for the time I had on sunny fall days and even in a foot of snow to watch children laugh and grow playing kickball. For me that was the best kind of paycheck.


Thursday, January 11, 2024

 Reading Assessments


You have to see where you are to know where you're going, right?  Every school I have worked in has used some kind of reading assessment at the start, middle and end of the school year.  In my Master's program at Hunter College I was trained (in the last century) to use Betty Roe’s Informal Reading Inventory.  I was given the opportunity to practice with students in a school in Chinatown. Fascinating! Those children spoke Mandarin as their first language and so I learned that in Chinese there are no plural nouns. There is a cat. There are two cat. There are many cat.  I learned this while doing the IRI with this Chinese boy. There are many things to learn from in an IRI beyond just the reading level of the student.


In Betty Roe’s IRI - like most IRIs - the student is given a graded list of words to say aloud at first. This allowed me to access the child's ability in phonics.  The lists continue to increase in difficulty and grade level. They also gave me a grade to start with in the reading passages. In true Betty Roe fashion, the child would be given passages to read silently and those to read aloud each type followed by questions. In reality, with 24 other students working quietly on something, I had time to only administer the read aloud passages.  These were also arranged by grade level. While the student read, I made miscue notations on a sheet with the same passage. Following their reading, I had a series of questions. The questions ranged from  vocabulary, main idea, inferencing, detail etc.  I also, unlike Betty, let students look back into the text. I wanted to see if they used that strategy or if they solely relied on their memory - not a great idea for many. The passages continued in complexity until the child reached a point where their comprehension broke down. All of this took 10 to 15 minutes for each child, a few a day. The IRI gave me a place to start in September and places to see growth in mid-year and in June.  It also gave me the opportunity to talk to the child about how they felt about reading and what kinds of things they liked to read.Or if they didn't like reading at all. It also gave me information on what that child needed to work on in particular. Did they have trouble making inferences? Were they a sight reader and not a phonics reader, something that is greatly overlooked in reading instruction. Do they have a dog? Do they have books at home? Are they nervous about 4th grade?  All of these things could be learned while administering the IRI.


Several years ago, my district moved to using Fountas and Pinell’s assessments. I tried to use them but found them sorely lacking in information about the student. Sure I could still ask them all those questions about their affective domain,  but there was no specific information about the components of reading that they needed to work on. The questions asked greatly depended on the intellect of the person giving the assessment. The timer to assess fluency made children nervous.  I went back to Betty Roe after a year or two.


At the end of my career, the district was using an online assessment that students took on their Chromebooks.  Nice and quick. These assessments kicked out a number. That's it, just a number to tell me and the district where each student was in their reading ability.


Now, I ask you which assessment is most valuable for the teacher? The one where I get to sit face to face with a child individually, hear them read, assess their miscues in phonics and comprehension and their strengths or one that gives me a number?


I still believe that elementary school is first and foremost a place where students learn to work and get along with people who are not their family. I believe elementary school is a place for children to make connections with their teacher. That time spent one to one with a child is so important. It goes well beyond just assessing their reading grade level.  And finally, do children really need to spend more time looking at screens?  I feel that online reading assessments are dehumanizing the whole point of early childhood education.