Tuesday, December 26, 2023

What We Say to Children

 What We Say to Children


I only have one memory of third grade and it wasn't good.  1968 was a rough year for me. My dad left our house. My mother was having a baby, which was shocking since I had been an only child for 8 years.  I remember when my grandmother passed me the phone and my mother was on the line asking if I'd like a baby brother or sister.  I knew that a father had to be involved in some way so I asked my mother “Where are we going to get one?”


So I had a lot on my mind that year and Mrs Delorme didn't help.  The picture of her, frozen in my memory, is of a scowling tight-lipped woman with a hairstyle that was 30 years out of date.  I think I was especially sensitive to her hairstyle because my mother spent a great deal of time and hairspray teasing her hair up to look like Tippi Hedren's.  Mrs DeLorme's hair was rolled as tight as her lips.


Each classroom in my elementary school had a piano in it.  The music teacher went from room to room.  I loved our music teacher Miss Kolaki.  She was the exact opposite of Mrs DeLorme. She was young. She smiled. She had long straight hair down the length of her back.  The whole feeling of the room changed when Miss Kolacki came in even though Mrs DeLorme remained. And I loved to sing.


Unfortunately in third grade I started having migraine headaches. These involved whole parts of my body- an arm, my face - going numb.  Maybe these headaches came upon me at this age because of genetics, my maternal grandmother had them as well or maybe they were because of the huge changes that were happening in my life. I'll never know. I did know, however, that they were very scary for my eight year old self.  They were especially scary because my mother, the biology teacher, didn't know what caused them or how to treat them. That was very disconcerting.


My soul memory of third grade was when Miss Kolaki came in from music.  A migraine started  Half my face and all of my tongue went completely numb.  While  the class was joyously singing, I went to Mrs DeLorme to ask if I could go to the nurse.  This ask was not easy since my tongue was completely numb.  She looked down at me with her pruned up face and said I was just trying to get out of singing. I was stunned. Why would anyone try to get out of singing?  I don't recall what happened after that but I have carried this memory of that woman all these years.


As teachers, we can never know what memories our students will carry with them into adulthood.  It is so important that we keep that idea in mind when we talk to our students. Will they remember us as someone who laughed and smiled and truly cared about them? Or will they carry a memory like mine?


I have done some digging into the life of Mrs DeLorme.  I wanted to try and understand why she assumed that a pudgy little Italian girl wouldn't want to sing.  She was from Mississippi. How she came to marry a man from Quebec who already had grown children Is a mystery, but she did.  She had taught younger grades in a smaller, neighboring town.  She was very involved in her church.  She had worked with or for a  woman whose last name was Leslie. Maybe she just didn't like me because of my name?  She became a widow in 1957 but she spent the next 9 years living in Gloversville.  My class was the last she had before she moved back to Quitman, Mississippi.  Perhaps she didn't hate me. Maybe she was just tired and hardened by life and anxious to leave upstate New York.


I could not know what was going on in her life as an 8-year-old. She probably had no idea what was going on in my life. The relationship between student and teacher is so profound.  It goes so far beyond reading and writing. I don't think teachers should ever forget that.


Sunday, December 17, 2023

 Black Books


Like many teachers, I had very little money by the end of the summer.  However, I spent over $100 every August to buy hardcover blank books for my new students.  I found them at A.C. Moore or Michaels.  The covers were usually black with 100 acid free pages.  Once I ordered them from Blick art supply but they were of such poor quality that they quickly fell apart in the hands of nine year olds.  I had to buy a whole new set.


A short-sighted principal once saw the black books piled in my classroom and emailed that I should “leave art to the art teacher.”  I did not.  He had no idea how I used the black books or why I was so devoted to using them.


In the first few days of school I would have students come up to me one at a time.  I’d ask them what name they would like on the page edges.  I used a Sharpie.  This way I would be able to tell whose book was whose from across the classroom.  It also gave me a chance to chat with them alone.  Eye contact early in the year leads to relationships.


Their first assignment in the black book was to draw their life - family, pets, hobbies, sports, etc.  This page would also be the opening of my parent/teacher conferences later in the year.  I instructed my students that they had to use the book chronologically - one page after another.  They also should date each page as they made entries in the book.  They were free to write or draw in the book as they wished but I would also assign different tasks.  I reminded them that I was only buying them one book for the year so they should not waste pages or space.


One of the most common tasks for the black book was a vocabulary chart.  Most of the schools where I taught used a basal reading series.  Each story had a corresponding vocabulary list and a glossary.  Students made 4 columns on a page in the black book and 10 rows.  There were usually 10 words.  The first column was for the word.  The second column was for the glossary definition.  I was never asked more than that from Mrs. Johnston, my high school English teacher.  (No shade on Mrs. Johnston though.  She was great.)  However, I wanted to up the ante for my students.  The third column was to define the word in the students' own words.  The fourth column was for an illustration of the word.  To put the word in an illustration, the students really needed to understand the meaning.  So many times, I was amazed at how students would visualize the word!  Sometimes I would laugh out loud as in the time Sabina drew a picture of a beret wearing, scruffy character standing before an abstract painting.  The speech bubble said, “Nope.”  She was illustrating the word critic.


Vocabulary charts could also be created for other content areas.  In Social Studies, I used them for NYS landforms.  In Science, we used them for the Simple Machines.  Vocabulary charts took time and thought.  They were a great assignment to have kids work on independently while other activities like Literature Circles were going on in the room.


There were many other uses for the black books.  Rough drafts for writing projects were in the black books.  I taught note taking in science.  Those notes went into the black books.  Flow charts for the writing process and steps in a project were in there.  I had my students draw a still life every week to improve their hand/eye coordination, their observational skills and their handwriting.  Those were done in the black books.


I loved that all these things were in one place along with what the child generated on their own.  Much like DaVinci’s notebooks, I could see the workings of each child’s mind in their book.  Students and I could see the progress they were making in this longitudinal journal.  During conferences parents could see this too, although it was a little disconcerting when we opened Brett’s book and found multiple drawings of toilet bowls with various contents.


At the end of each year the Seniors do a walk through of their elementary school in their cap and gown.  Afterward there is a meet and greet on the playground.  I always asked my former students if they still have their black books.  Invariably, they say that they do.  I think that is wonderful!  In this day and age when so much is left in a virtual world, what kind of records will children have of their lives?  I am so happy that they still have an artifact from their youth.


https://www.michaels.com/product/hardbound-sketchbook-by-artists-loft-85-x-11-10449298?michaelsStore=9955&inv=9


Thursday, December 14, 2023

 Cursive


The other day I overheard 2 people in the doctor’s waiting room talking about how “kids today don’t even know how to sign their name.”  I have heard this many times over the last few years.  Once I wrote a note in a student’s agenda to their parents.  The child came back the next day and said that their parents could not read cursive.


I cannot, for the life of me, understand why teaching cursive has fallen by the wayside.  Nothing could be easier to teach!  At the very start of the year, I distributed cursive packets to my students.  I liked the way letters were organized in the particular book that I used.  There were loopy letters like l, b, f, d, h etc.  “Clock Climbers” like c, a, o.  Mountains and valleys like m, n, v, u.  Each day, usually during snack, I played a YouTube video that showed students how to make one of the letters.  There are many such videos from which to choose and my students really enjoyed them.  Then I would give my students five to ten minutes to practice that letter.  Five to ten blissful minutes when they were quietly focused on the task.  Just one letter a day for 10 minutes.  After 26 days,, I would pass out a morning worksheet that focused on one letter which was used in words and short sentences.  At the end of the day, I would select the nicest penmanship and the most improved writer.  Eventually, after 26 more days I would assign a cursive paragraph to copy as weekly homework.  It went out on Friday and was returned the following Friday.  These paragraphs all had something to do with American history - The Constitution, The Liberty Bell, Pony Express, etc.  They were getting two birds with this assignment - cursive and Social Studies.  By Thanksgiving all my students could read and write in cursive.  Weekly homework assignments for the rest of the year included touch typing practice at home.


I believe there are a tremendous number of reasons why children should learn cursive.  Let’s start with focus.  As I mentioned, the classroom went nearly silent when my students practiced their letters.  Much as I loved the peacefulness of this, it was more important to me that my students were practicing sustained focus.  In their fast paced world of screens, how often does that happen?  As the fall went on, I saw daily improvement in my students’ small motor skills. They cannot rely on texting thumbs for everything in their future.  Some youngsters will grow up to become surgeons, electricians or hair stylists where small motor skills will be essential if not life saving.  Multiple studies like that of  Pam Mueller of Princeton, show that students retain more when taking notes by hand.  Cursive is faster for note taking than print.  And how about the  simple beauty of penmanship?  Steve Jobs credited a calligraphy class with how Apple was able to develop multiple typefaces and proportionally spaced fonts.  These are only a few reasons why students should learn cursive, but I think they are pretty powerful reasons.


Why would we choose to keep children from learning cursive?  The trend started when the much hated Common Core dropped cursive as a standard.  The Common Core has been found to be deeply flawed so let’s bring cursive back.  Some will say that students don’t need cursive since the future of writing will be on a keyboard or with voice recognition.  Would it make sense to make the same argument for students to skip learning their multiplication facts since a calculator is always available?  They might also say that our cherished documents like the Constitution have been transcribed in print.  True enough, but that means that content is shared through the filter of an interpreter.  There’s a slippery slope!  What about cherished personal documents?  If you couldn’t read cursive, what would you have to do when you found a stack of love letters to and from your grandparents as you sat in the quiet of their dusty attic?  Get an interpreter?


Another argument that I have heard is that there is so much more content to teach these days.  That is true.  However, my 4th grade Social Studies curriculum was to cover New York State history from the wooly mammoth through the Industrial Revolution along with the 3 branches of government and our neighbors Canada and Mexico.  It is not possible to cover all that in any meaningful way.  Not to mention that there is still reading, writing, science and math to teach.  Perhaps school districts should restructure their priorities to focus on skills which would be truly useful for a lifetime and not as much on content.


Cursive is easy to learn in the random moments of the elementary school day.  It is a powerful tool.  I hope that this will encourage teachers to bring cursive back.




Wednesday, December 13, 2023

 Morning Meeting


Many, many years ago I had a very difficult fifth grade class. They were like a volcano ready to blow at the slightest tremor in the earth.  I had (what I thought was) the brilliant idea to have a meeting each morning to build a level of camaraderie.  It was a disaster of too many talking at once, feelings being hurt and very little control from me.


Thankfully, I discovered “The Morning Meeting Book”  by Carol Davis and Roxanne Kriete.  https://www.amazon.com/Morning-Meeting-Book-Roxann-Kriete/dp/1892989603  This book was a raft to swim out to with structure on how to run a morning meeting.  Keep in mind that I discovered this book over 25 years ago. I'm not sure how much of my morning meetings came from the book or my own “brilliant” inventions but I'll describe how I ran a meeting.  As my initial instinct was correct, the daily meeting became an essential tool for camaraderie, caring and social emotional learning.  I never gave it up even in the face of excessive testing and a data crazed administrator.


Kids would come to the Morning Meeting and circle up on the rug.  Some classes needed to sit boy/girl to avoid distracting clicks, but most classes were just fine self-selecting their seats.  During social distancing students stayed at their desks but it never really had the same feel as the circle on the rug.


I would choose which student would start “Good Morning.”  That student would look to one next to them, make eye contact and say “Good morning Emily,” for example.   Initially, it took some reminding that it wasn't a time for silly voices or any other type of nonsense. Good morning needed to be a sincere wish for the other person to in fact have a good morning.  It was a beautiful thing to watch that good morning go all the way around the circle.


Next up, I would choose an event from that day in history. In order to give students a frame of reference, I would always include a comparison to the year. For example, if it was April 14, 1912 - the day the Titanic sank - I would say my grandfather was 12 on that day.


Then I had the science mystery of the day from the book “65 Short Mysteries You Can Solve with Science.” https://www.amazon.com/One-Minute-Mysteries-Short-Science/dp/0967802016/ref=pd_bxgy_img_d_sccl_1/142-2905997-6930556?pd_rd_w=LKMmM&content-id=amzn1.sym.7746dde5-5539-43d2-b75f-28935d70f100&pf_rd_p=7746dde5-5539-43d2-b75f-28935d70f100&pf_rd_r=MTPNFMYZG79PT1QJA2CE&pd_rd_wg=UAJsY&pd_rd_r=09b370b6-7534-4ec5-8e6e-ca75e3f57d5c&pd_rd_i=0967802016&psc=1  Loved this book!  These are one minute mysteries. I would read the scenario in the day's mystery and stop to ask for solutions. Everyone who had their hand up shared their solution. Kids had some difficulty, especially early in the year when they were still very egocentric, with realizing that someone else had just said the same solution. But I wanted to make sure everyone who had their hand up had an opportunity to speak for multiple reasons. First, because hearing multiple solutions allowed me, after the fact, to correct any misunderstandings a student might have about science. Water does not flow in from the ocean but down from the mountains, for example. Except for a fjord of course. Also hearing all the possible solutions let one student's idea build off another. Isn't that what science is all about after all?  After hearing all the solutions, I would read the conclusion. My students would choose whose answer had been most correct.  Most of the time they were right. That student earned a prize from the prize drawer.  A note on the prize drawer. It was filled with all manner of random objects. Normal things like erasers and pencils but what students every year preferred were carpet samples from Home Depot, which were free. Go figure! I always let them choose between three prizes. They need to have opportunities to make choices.  I don't think kids these days have enough opportunities to make their own choices.  A pencil, a dog show ribbon (which I had a lot of because I was the show chairperson for my club) or a laminate flooring sample. They'd always choose the flooring sample!


All this happened in quick, orderly succession. Then we moved on to problems, plans, celebrations, worries, wonders and thinks.  In the first few days of the year I would introduce each one of these.  After a few weeks I would choose a student to run the meeting from this point.  First there were problems. We've all got them! Kids are no exception. When a child shared their problem they could hear advice from two of their peers. Suggestions needed to be something the child could actually do. No you cannot suggest that they punch their sister for going into their room. And it had to be a suggestion which might actually solve the problem. Early on, I saw that students would immediately deflect any suggestion. I guess it's just human nature to believe our problems are unsolvable or maybe it's just martyrdom. At any rate, I made a rule that the martyr just needed to say “Thank you for your advice.” I felt that it was important for children to know that we all have problems and that we can reach out to peers for help.


Plans were just that - events coming up. Students shared upcoming swim meets and soccer matches along with travel destinations. Some students knew each other very well in and out of school but others did not. I thought it was important for classmates to know what was going on in the lives of their peers. Celebrations followed the same tact. “My Stella won a major at the dog show this weekend!” I also thought they should know what was going on in my life too.


Worries could also result in advice from two peers. Children worry about all kinds of things, big and small. “I'm worried about my dance recital.” “I'm worried about state tests.” One student said that she was worried about China and the United States going to war because her family was from China but was living here. She was worried about who she should support.


Wonders and Thinks are nearly the same thing with the exception that wonders could garner responses from two peers like problems and worries. My example of wonders was what would happen to an ant that was crawling on my windshield as I drove miles away from his colony. Would he join another colony where I had parked? Would he be attacked by a new colony? Would he die of loneliness? I had a student who seemed to have a wonder nearly every day.  After a few weeks, when Rohan raised his hand and said he had a wonder his peers groaned. I reminded them that wonders are the start of all science.  “I wonder why the moon changes shape,” said someone thousands of years ago. That stopped the groaning! One child said she was thinking about her grandpa who had passed away. That was all.  It wasn't really a problem. She was just thinking about him.


Yes - all this can be done in half an hour. I believe it was the most important half hour of the day.  On teacher Facebook groups, I have read about so many teachers having problems with student behavior.  Did I have a problem with student behaviors? Of course I did! But I fully believe that I had less of them because of our morning meetings. I never had a group of catty girls or bullying boys in the years that I used the morning meeting. Never. I truly believed it was because Morning Meeting was a place to vent and share problems or to celebrate together. Morning Meeting literally and figuratively brought us together and kept us together.