Wednesday, December 13, 2023

 Morning Meeting


Many, many years ago I had a very difficult fifth grade class. They were like a volcano ready to blow at the slightest tremor in the earth.  I had (what I thought was) the brilliant idea to have a meeting each morning to build a level of camaraderie.  It was a disaster of too many talking at once, feelings being hurt and very little control from me.


Thankfully, I discovered “The Morning Meeting Book”  by Carol Davis and Roxanne Kriete.  https://www.amazon.com/Morning-Meeting-Book-Roxann-Kriete/dp/1892989603  This book was a raft to swim out to with structure on how to run a morning meeting.  Keep in mind that I discovered this book over 25 years ago. I'm not sure how much of my morning meetings came from the book or my own “brilliant” inventions but I'll describe how I ran a meeting.  As my initial instinct was correct, the daily meeting became an essential tool for camaraderie, caring and social emotional learning.  I never gave it up even in the face of excessive testing and a data crazed administrator.


Kids would come to the Morning Meeting and circle up on the rug.  Some classes needed to sit boy/girl to avoid distracting clicks, but most classes were just fine self-selecting their seats.  During social distancing students stayed at their desks but it never really had the same feel as the circle on the rug.


I would choose which student would start “Good Morning.”  That student would look to one next to them, make eye contact and say “Good morning Emily,” for example.   Initially, it took some reminding that it wasn't a time for silly voices or any other type of nonsense. Good morning needed to be a sincere wish for the other person to in fact have a good morning.  It was a beautiful thing to watch that good morning go all the way around the circle.


Next up, I would choose an event from that day in history. In order to give students a frame of reference, I would always include a comparison to the year. For example, if it was April 14, 1912 - the day the Titanic sank - I would say my grandfather was 12 on that day.


Then I had the science mystery of the day from the book “65 Short Mysteries You Can Solve with Science.” https://www.amazon.com/One-Minute-Mysteries-Short-Science/dp/0967802016/ref=pd_bxgy_img_d_sccl_1/142-2905997-6930556?pd_rd_w=LKMmM&content-id=amzn1.sym.7746dde5-5539-43d2-b75f-28935d70f100&pf_rd_p=7746dde5-5539-43d2-b75f-28935d70f100&pf_rd_r=MTPNFMYZG79PT1QJA2CE&pd_rd_wg=UAJsY&pd_rd_r=09b370b6-7534-4ec5-8e6e-ca75e3f57d5c&pd_rd_i=0967802016&psc=1  Loved this book!  These are one minute mysteries. I would read the scenario in the day's mystery and stop to ask for solutions. Everyone who had their hand up shared their solution. Kids had some difficulty, especially early in the year when they were still very egocentric, with realizing that someone else had just said the same solution. But I wanted to make sure everyone who had their hand up had an opportunity to speak for multiple reasons. First, because hearing multiple solutions allowed me, after the fact, to correct any misunderstandings a student might have about science. Water does not flow in from the ocean but down from the mountains, for example. Except for a fjord of course. Also hearing all the possible solutions let one student's idea build off another. Isn't that what science is all about after all?  After hearing all the solutions, I would read the conclusion. My students would choose whose answer had been most correct.  Most of the time they were right. That student earned a prize from the prize drawer.  A note on the prize drawer. It was filled with all manner of random objects. Normal things like erasers and pencils but what students every year preferred were carpet samples from Home Depot, which were free. Go figure! I always let them choose between three prizes. They need to have opportunities to make choices.  I don't think kids these days have enough opportunities to make their own choices.  A pencil, a dog show ribbon (which I had a lot of because I was the show chairperson for my club) or a laminate flooring sample. They'd always choose the flooring sample!


All this happened in quick, orderly succession. Then we moved on to problems, plans, celebrations, worries, wonders and thinks.  In the first few days of the year I would introduce each one of these.  After a few weeks I would choose a student to run the meeting from this point.  First there were problems. We've all got them! Kids are no exception. When a child shared their problem they could hear advice from two of their peers. Suggestions needed to be something the child could actually do. No you cannot suggest that they punch their sister for going into their room. And it had to be a suggestion which might actually solve the problem. Early on, I saw that students would immediately deflect any suggestion. I guess it's just human nature to believe our problems are unsolvable or maybe it's just martyrdom. At any rate, I made a rule that the martyr just needed to say “Thank you for your advice.” I felt that it was important for children to know that we all have problems and that we can reach out to peers for help.


Plans were just that - events coming up. Students shared upcoming swim meets and soccer matches along with travel destinations. Some students knew each other very well in and out of school but others did not. I thought it was important for classmates to know what was going on in the lives of their peers. Celebrations followed the same tact. “My Stella won a major at the dog show this weekend!” I also thought they should know what was going on in my life too.


Worries could also result in advice from two peers. Children worry about all kinds of things, big and small. “I'm worried about my dance recital.” “I'm worried about state tests.” One student said that she was worried about China and the United States going to war because her family was from China but was living here. She was worried about who she should support.


Wonders and Thinks are nearly the same thing with the exception that wonders could garner responses from two peers like problems and worries. My example of wonders was what would happen to an ant that was crawling on my windshield as I drove miles away from his colony. Would he join another colony where I had parked? Would he be attacked by a new colony? Would he die of loneliness? I had a student who seemed to have a wonder nearly every day.  After a few weeks, when Rohan raised his hand and said he had a wonder his peers groaned. I reminded them that wonders are the start of all science.  “I wonder why the moon changes shape,” said someone thousands of years ago. That stopped the groaning! One child said she was thinking about her grandpa who had passed away. That was all.  It wasn't really a problem. She was just thinking about him.


Yes - all this can be done in half an hour. I believe it was the most important half hour of the day.  On teacher Facebook groups, I have read about so many teachers having problems with student behavior.  Did I have a problem with student behaviors? Of course I did! But I fully believe that I had less of them because of our morning meetings. I never had a group of catty girls or bullying boys in the years that I used the morning meeting. Never. I truly believed it was because Morning Meeting was a place to vent and share problems or to celebrate together. Morning Meeting literally and figuratively brought us together and kept us together.


No comments:

Post a Comment